If you’ve been following my reviews for a while now, you might have caught on that I’ve become a big fan of the independent film company A24. They consistently take gambles on projects for up and coming directors and many of them end up being art house hits. The past few years have also featured a lot of directorial debuts, many of them coming from current actors like John Krasinski, Bradley Cooper, and Bo Burnham (Eighth Grade is from A24). Actor Jonah Hill’s film Mid90s is one of the rare misfires in A24’s impressive library of independent hits.
Growing up in the 90s, I had anticipated the film to hit me right in the nostalgia bone and take me back to when times were much simpler and free. The film does that for the opening 15 minutes or so, just trying really hard to let you know that yes, we are currently in the 90s. It even has that grainy texture from early 90s movies. However, it gets old pretty quick and feels a bit forced, as it doesn’t have the natural progression of taking you back like a film like Boyhood. Once it conveys its time capsule effect, it goes straight into the skate culture that pervaded many 90s adolescents.
The main problem I had with this film is that it sets up a lot of great characters, such as Lucas Hedges (isn’t this guy everywhere now?) as the older brother of main character Sunny Suljic (Atreus!), and Katherine Waterston as the mother of the dysfunctional family. Suljic’s skater friends are a bit hit and miss, as some of their eccentricities feel more like caricatures of skaters as opposed to actual human beings. However, there are some great character moments between Suljic’s Stevie and leader of the skating group Ray, played by Na-Kel Smith. The small character-building moments that this movie shares are overshadowed by Hill’s attempt to generate shock value by making these kids do edgy things because of the skater culture they grew into.
This movie isn’t very long as it runs just under 90 minutes, so it’s all the more disappointing that it uses up most of the time with scenes of these kids going to parties and doing things that’ll make your inner parent disappointed. The film becomes a bit too self-indulgent in this aspect, when it could have explored a lot of interesting relationships with the fantastic actors put together.
Hill has a potential to be a great director, but his writing and tone of the film keep it from being a great coming of age film. He gets so caught up in wanting to capture the edginess of skater culture in the 90s, that he forgets to tell an intimate story with the pieces that he’s been given.
Grade: C+/70