Guillermo Del Toro’s newest film The Shape of Water is an unconventional romantic drama that tells the tale of a mute woman who falls in love with a fish guy. Yep, you read that right. If you haven’t heard any of the Oscar buzz around this movie, then know that it has a really good chance of winning best picture. This film has all the hallmarks of something that Hollywood would love. It is beautifully directed, acted, and tells a very poignant message that is reflective of our current times and political climate. This is easily the most progressive movie I’ve ever seen, and it couldn’t have come out at a more relevant time.
There is definitely an undeniable charm to this film. GDT is an excellent director and filmmaker; he has a very imaginative eye for cinema and all his previous movies have shown that. The setting of this film, coupled with great music from Alexandre Desplat, really conveys a sense of wonder and magic in every shot. Sally Hawkins is absolutely wonderful in her performance as the main character. She is able to show a lot of her emotions even though she can’t utter a single word, and there’s one specific scene where I was really impressed with her performance.
As much as I am heaping praise upon praise on this movie, I ended up not really liking it. That all comes down to one thing: this movie made me uncomfortable. I understand that it’s basically like a Beauty and the Beast type movie for adults, but a lot of the scenes made me uncomfortable watching. Many of the antagonists are very one-dimensional, and similar to my review of characters in Three Billboards, they are very much caricatures of stereotypical characters. It was hard for me to buy into the romance between Sally Hawkins and the fish man, mostly due to the animalistic nature of the fish. It was difficult to be invested in both characters, even though Sally Hawkins was fantastic in her role.
I very much wanted to like this film. It’s beautifully directed and created, but I couldn’t buy into the story or the characters. It’s a bit too preachy at times, but ultimately the main thing was that I felt uneasy during most of the movie. The story is really out there and didn’t do it for me. I think some people will absolutely love this movie because they will love the romance between the two, but I just couldn’t get into it. However, I’m glad to see that GDT is always doing his thing and continues to make unique and original movies. I look forward to seeing what’s in store for him next.
Grade: C/62