Never underestimate the power of a well-told story. That was the lesson I learned when I watched Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri last night.
To preface this review, I wanted to share that I initially had zero interest in watching this movie. I saw the trailer because I had no idea what it was, and I’m only slightly familiar with some of Martin McDonagh’s work (thought In Bruges was pretty good, hated Seven Psychopaths). Based on the trailer and reading about the premise, my understanding of the film was that it was about a woman who erects three billboards in the small town of Ebbing, Missouri that criticizes the police for not solving the murder of her teenage daughter. I thought to myself, oh great. A politically-charged movie in some of the most politically-charged times. I can’t wait to see Hollywood’s take on how they feel about white America and law enforcement. I pretty much went into this movie already thinking I was going to hate it, and guess what? I did.
This movie is written in a near comical fashion. All of the characters are caricatures of extreme stereotypes, especially that of the Ebbing Police Department. Every police officer is portrayed as utterly pathetic and immoral, completely incapable of actually serving and protecting their town’s citizens. The main character, played by Frances McDormand seems to be surrounded by unrealistically deplorable characters that seek to do nothing but cause suffering in her life. Most of the movie just sets itself up as an incredibly over-the-top criticism of law enforcement and how they literally do nothing but care for themselves. Everything that was happening in the movie sucked me out of the story because of how unrealistic everything was being portrayed. I thought to myself, if this movie continues to be this one-sided, this is going to be the worst movie I’ve seen all year. Then, out of nowhere, the movie completely redeemed itself with an amazing third act.
I’m not entirely sure how to explain the drastic turnaround for this movie, but I’ll try my best. It starts with the characters. Sam Rockwell, who plays one of the doofuses in the Ebbing Police Department, gives arguably his best performance I’ve seen from him. He goes from being an utterly unredeemable character to so much more, and his performance perfectly captures that. Frances McDormand also demonstrates her acting chops by giving an incredibly powerful performance that really seems to stretch her character throughout the film. Many of the characters that initially seem one-sided at first begin to show other facets of their personality that are fleshed out in a very authentic and believable way. Obviously I won’t spoil anything, but I think the movie does a great job of rewarding you for being patient with these characters, which result in some great payoffs for certain characters, regardless of whether it’s a happy or sad ending.
One thing to keep in mind is that this movie is a dark comedy, which is a very hit or miss genre for me. McDonagh specializes in this genre with his biting and sharp writing, which oftentimes works but can be divisive. The writing in this movie is very vulgar, but poignant. It’s also very funny throughout, even during the times when I felt miserable watching it. Although the first two-thirds of the movie are written in an infuriatingly one-sided fashion, McDonagh does an incredible job making everything come full circle. McDormand’s character no longer becomes the suffering saint, as she begins to do things equally as deplorable as the police officers. Rockwell’s character begins to not be such a doofus. Everything begins to unravel and the world isn’t so black and white anymore. The more I think about it, the more I begin to realize that the poor portrayal of the police department was intentional and not just the directors way of criticizing white America. It was his way of leading you on this story that seems so unrealistic at first, then really grounds you in the last third of the movie.
The best way I can comprehend the viewing of this movie is to see it like a fairy tale. In fairy tales, most characters are not very complex and have a very black-and-white view on things. They have one defining characteristic, and it is the driving force of everything they do. However, fairy tales often have powerful messages that are told with very simplistic characters. Three Billboards is very much a modern fairy tale, as it has very important messages on how we view law enforcement, crime, and other human beings. It also teaches us about reconciliation and forgiveness, and is done so very effectively. The film is told in a way that seems incredibly fictional at first, even though it’s grounded in reality. McDonagh’s direction with this movie really drags you through a sewer of crap that ultimately lead you to the room filled with treasure. While I think that the first two-thirds of the movie could have been less ridiculous, it did serve its purpose in really rewarding the viewer for sticking through with it.
I think I can confidently say that no movie has ever made me feel the things I felt like Three Billboards did. I’ve never hated a movie so much and then end up really enjoying it. While it did make for a very agonizing viewing experience, the payoffs in the end were worth it, even though I think some people will be put off by the ending. The story is written in a very powerful way that really caused me to think of my own prejudices and how I feel about people with different viewpoints. Criticism is good, and should be welcomed by all beliefs in life. Law enforcement is not perfect, and neither are those that they are protecting. This movie is a story about that, and how tragedy can oftentimes be humorous. This movie will definitely not be for everyone, but I think it creates a journey worth taking. It is a powerful story led by some Oscar-worthy performances, ultimately making for a dark comedy that captures the plight of our generation incredibly well.
Grade: B+/81